투고논문
Abstract
References
Information
This article examines the four-line gāthā (四句偈) inscribed on a copy of the Lotus Sūtra (『法華經』) and an Amitābha Buddha Painting (阿彌陀如來圖) commissioned by Yŏm Sŭngik (廉承益), a powerful court favorite during the reign of King Ch’ungnyŏl (忠烈王). Although previous scholars have proposed various interpretations of the source of this gāthā, this study argues that it derives from the Linian Mituo Daochang Chanfa (禮念彌陀道場懺法), a repentance liturgy widely circulated in thirteenth- and fourteenth-century Koryŏ Buddhism.
In the Buddhist ritual practices of late Koryŏ, ch’ambŏp (懺法, repentance rites) were highly valued across sectarian boundaries. This period, particularly under the influence of the Buddhist kyeolsa (結社, devotional association) movement, placed unprecedented emphasis on devotional practice. Within this context, ch’ambŏp, as rituals of repentance, came to occupy an especially important position because their ultimate aim was to eradicate karmic transgressions through repentance and achieve rebirth in the Pure Land. Repentance thus emerged as one of the most significant themes in late Koryŏ Buddhism, regardless of sectarian affiliation. For this reason, Yŏm Sŭngik likely selected the four-line gāthā—the central passage of this text—and inscribed it on the sūtra transcription and Buddhist painting as an expression of repentance and aspiration for rebirth in the Pure Land.
The popularity of this gāthā is further demonstrated by its citation in more than sixty Buddhist scriptures through the mid-twentieth century. Among the more than sixty texts in the Chinese Buddhist canon that cite this gāthā, however, only two—the forty-fascicleHuayan jing (大方廣佛華嚴經, Avataṃsaka Sūtra) and the Linian Mituo Daochang Chanfa —were included in the Koryŏ Taejanggyŏng (『高麗大藏經』, Koryŏ Buddhist Canon). This textual circumstance further supports the argument advanced in this study. The article also suggests that when Sunam Ŭisŏn (順庵 義璇) republished the Linian Mituo Daochang Chanfa in China in 1332 and subsequently disseminated it in Koryŏ, the project may have been shaped by the influence of Cho In’gyu (趙仁規), his father, and Yŏm Sŭngik, his relative by marriage.
In the Buddhist ritual practices of late Koryŏ, ch’ambŏp (懺法, repentance rites) were highly valued across sectarian boundaries. This period, particularly under the influence of the Buddhist kyeolsa (結社, devotional association) movement, placed unprecedented emphasis on devotional practice. Within this context, ch’ambŏp, as rituals of repentance, came to occupy an especially important position because their ultimate aim was to eradicate karmic transgressions through repentance and achieve rebirth in the Pure Land. Repentance thus emerged as one of the most significant themes in late Koryŏ Buddhism, regardless of sectarian affiliation. For this reason, Yŏm Sŭngik likely selected the four-line gāthā—the central passage of this text—and inscribed it on the sūtra transcription and Buddhist painting as an expression of repentance and aspiration for rebirth in the Pure Land.
The popularity of this gāthā is further demonstrated by its citation in more than sixty Buddhist scriptures through the mid-twentieth century. Among the more than sixty texts in the Chinese Buddhist canon that cite this gāthā, however, only two—the forty-fascicle
이 글에서 필자는 충렬왕때의 폐행(嬖幸) 염승익이 발원한 <『법화경』사경>과 <아미타여래도>에 적힌 사구게(四句偈)에 주목했다. 이와 관련하여 관련 연구자들이 다양한 결론을 도출했지만, 필자는 염승익이 인용한 사구게의 출처는 13-14세기 고려에서 유행했던 참회의 의식집인 『예념미타도량참법(禮念彌陀道場懺法)』이라고 추정했다. 고려 후기 불교의례에서 참법은 종파를 초월하여 중시되었다. 이 시기는 특히 결사(結社)불교 운동의 영향으로 그 어느 때보다 실천 신앙이 강조되던 때이다. 이에 따라 ‘참회의 의례’인 ‘참법’을 매우 중요하게 여겼는데, 참법은 참회를 통해 멸죄하고 결국 극락으로 왕생하는 것이 목적이다. ‘참회’는 종파를 초월하여 고려 후기 불교계의 가장 중요한 주제였으며, 이런 이유로 염승익은 이 책의 핵심인 사구게를 선택해 사경과 불화에 적어넣어 자신의 바람이 이뤄지기를 기대했을 것이라 추정했다.
염승익 발원 불교미술에 적힌 사구게는 20세기 중엽까지 60여종의 경전에 인용될 만큼 인기있었다. 그러나 사구게를 인용한 한문대장경 60여종 가운데 『고려대장경』에 입장(入藏)된 것은 40권본 『대방광불화엄경』과 『예념미타도량참법』, 단 2종뿐이라는 점도 필자의 주장을 뒷받침한다. 충렬왕의 폐행, 염승익은 『예념미타도량참법』의 마지막 사구게를 인용하며 참회로 멸죄하고 극락왕생하기를 바랐을 것이다. 아울러 1332년 중국에서 고려 승려 순암 의선(順庵 義璇, 1284?-1355)이 『예념미타도량참법』을 중간(重刊)하여 고려에 유포한 것도 의선의 아버지 조인규, 사돈어른인 염승익의 영향이 있었을 것이라 추정했다.
염승익 발원 불교미술에 적힌 사구게는 20세기 중엽까지 60여종의 경전에 인용될 만큼 인기있었다. 그러나 사구게를 인용한 한문대장경 60여종 가운데 『고려대장경』에 입장(入藏)된 것은 40권본 『대방광불화엄경』과 『예념미타도량참법』, 단 2종뿐이라는 점도 필자의 주장을 뒷받침한다. 충렬왕의 폐행, 염승익은 『예념미타도량참법』의 마지막 사구게를 인용하며 참회로 멸죄하고 극락왕생하기를 바랐을 것이다. 아울러 1332년 중국에서 고려 승려 순암 의선(順庵 義璇, 1284?-1355)이 『예념미타도량참법』을 중간(重刊)하여 고려에 유포한 것도 의선의 아버지 조인규, 사돈어른인 염승익의 영향이 있었을 것이라 추정했다.
- T
Taishō shinshū daizōkyō 大正新修大藏經 - X
Manji Zokuzōkyō 卍續藏經 - K Koryŏ Daejanggyeong 高麗大藏經
- 『高麗史(Koryŏ-sa)』
- 『高麗史節要(Koryŏ-sa chŏryo)』
- 『大方廣佛華嚴經(Dafangguang Fo Huayan Jing, Avatamsaka Sutra)』 T.10 293; K.1262 36.
- 『大乘起信論疏記會本(Taesŭngkisinnon Soki Hoebon)』
- 『東文選(Tongmun sŏn)』
- 『佛說無量壽經(Foshuo Wuliangshou Jing, Sukhāvatīvyūha Sūtra)』 T.12 360.
- 『禮念彌陀道場懺法(Linian Mituo Daochang Chanfa)』 X.74 1467; K.1511 47.
- 『往生集(Wangsheng Ji)』 T.51 2072.
- 『淨土往生傳(Jingtu Wangsheng Zhuan)』 T.51 2071.
- Byeon Gye-ryang 卞季良, 『春亭集(Chunjŏng-jip)』
- Yi Je-hyeon 李齋賢, 『益哉亂藁(Ikchae Nango)』
- Yi Kok 李穀, 『稼亭集(Gajeongjip)』
- Yi Saek 李穡, 『牧隱文藁(Mokeunmoongo)』
- CHOE, Jae-Jin 최재진. 1996. 「『고려사』 열전의 폐행전 연구」 (“A Study About Pyehaengjon Stories in Koryo History”), 『동서사학』 (
Journal of East–West Historical Studies ), vol. 2, 1-29. - CHUNG, Woothak 鄭于澤. 1988. 「日本銀行藏(東京國立博物館寄託)の阿彌陀如來圖」 (“Painting of amitabha Buddha donated to Tokyo national Museum by the Bank of Japan”), 『MUSEUM』, vol. 453, 17-34.
- GO, Yu-Seop 高裕燮. 1979. 「開國寺와 南溪院」 (“Gaeguksa Temple and Namgyewon”), 『松都의 古蹟』 (
Historical relics of Songdo ), Paju: Yeolhwadang 悅話堂. - GUI, Xi-peng 桂栖鹏. 2001. 「人元高丽僧人考略」 (“A Textual Study of the Gaoli's Buddhist Monks Who Came to China During the Yuan Dynasty”), 『西北师大学报(社会科学版)』 (
Journal of Zhejiang Normal University ), vol. 38-2, 58-62. - HWANG, Ingyu 黃仁奎. 1998. 「趙仁規家門과 水原 萬義寺」 (“The Cho In-gyu Family and Maneuisa Temple in Suwon”), 『수원문화사연구』 (
Journal of Suwon Cultural History Studies ), vol. 2, 78-95. - 황인규. 2003. 「Ⅳ. 원나라 간섭기 조인규 가문과 천태종승: 권문세족과 불교계의 동향 일 사례」 (“The Jo In-gyu Family and Cheontae Buddhist Monks during the Yuan Intervention Period: A Case Study of Trends among Aristocratic Families and the Buddhist Community”), 『고려후기·조선초 불교사 연구』 (
History of Medieval Buddhism ), Seoul: Hyean 혜안, 226-249. - Junhyoung Michael Shin. 2005. “Iconographic Surrogates: Contemplating Amitabha Images in the Late Koryo dynasty (Fourteenth Century),”
Archives of Asian Art 55, 1-15. 10.1484/aaa.2005.0001 - KANG, Hosun 강호선. 2019. 「고려후기 백련결사에 대한 재검토」 (“A Review of White Lotus Community (白蓮結社) in the Late Goryeo Period”), 『불교학연구』 (
Journal of Buddhist Studies ), vol. 58, 115-143. 10.21482/jbs.58..201903.115 - _______. 2001. 「원간섭기 천태종단의 변화-충렬・충선왕대 묘련사계를 중심으로」 (“The Changes Occurred inside the Koryǒ Ch'ǒnt'ai School during the reigns of King Ch'ungnyǒl and Ch'ungsǒn: A Case Study of the M'yor'yǒn Temple Group”), 『보조사상』 (
Journal of Bojo Jinul's Thought ), vol. 16, 333-375. - _______. 2020. 「13~14세기의 대장경 인출·유통과 고려대장경」 (“A Study on the Printing and Circulation of Tripitaka in the East Asia and Tripitaka Koreana in the 13th and 14th centuries”), 『한국문화』 (
Journal of Korean Culture ), vol. 91, 2020, 37-69. - KIM, Do-yun 김도윤. 2022. 「여말선초 『예념미타도량참법』의 전래와 전개 -『소미타참』의 유래와 관련하여-」 (“Introduction and Development of the Lǐniànmítuódàochǎngchànfǎ (禮念彌陀道場懺法) during late Goryeo and early Joseon ― in connection with Xiǎomítuóchàn(小彌陀懺) ―”), 『한국불교사연구』 (
Journal of Korean Buddhist History ), vol. 22, 333-363. - KIM, Jeongmin 김종민. 2019. 「감지금자 『百千印陁羅尼經四經合部』 사경을 통해 본 고려시대 왕실발원 사경 - 충렬왕대의 국왕발원사경을 중심으로」 (“A Study on the manuscript sutra originated by royal family in Goryeo Dynasty through the overall compilation in golf on indigo paper 『Baegchenin-dalanigyeonghapbu』 - Focused on the manuscript sutra patronized during the time of King Chungryul”), 『불교미술사학』 (
Journal of Buddhist Art History ), vol. 28, 347-370. 10.36620/BMS.2019.28.14 - KIM, Junghee 김정희. 2001. 「고려왕실의 불화제작과 왕실발원불화의 연구」 (“A Study on Buddhist Paintings Sponsored by the Royal Family of Goryo Dynasty”), 『강좌미술사』 (
Art History Journal ), vol. 17, 127-153. - KIM, Yong-seon 김용선, tr. 2006. 『역주 고려묘지명집성(하)』 (
Collection of Goryeo Dynasty Epitaphs , vol. 2), Chuncheon: Hallym University Press 한림대학교 출판부. - KWON, Hi-Kyung 권희경. 2003. 「사경원과 염승익 발원의 사경 『묘법연화경』 7권본 1부」 (“A Study on the set of seven scrolls of the Saddarma Pundarika Sutra Prayed by Yeom Seong-Ik and Script Center”), 『한국기록학회지』 (
Journal of Records Management & Archives Society of Korea ), vol. 3, 1-22. - KYE, Mihyang 계미향. 2022. 「고려 의선(義璇)의 삼장법사 법호 고찰」 (“A Study on how Yìxuán (義旋) was appointed as a tripiṭaka-ācārya”), 『한국불교학』 (
Journal of the Korean Association for Buddhist Studies ), vol. 101, 221-250. 10.22255/JKABS.101.8. - LEE, Seunghui 이승희. 2011. 「高麗後期 淨土佛敎繪畵의 硏究 : 天台·華嚴신앙의 요소를 중심으로」 (“A study of the pure land Buddhist painting of the late Goryeo dynasty : with a focus on elements of Cheontae and Hwaeom Buddhism”), PhD diss., Hongik university 홍익대학교 대학원 박사학위 청구논문.
- LIM, Young-ae 임영애. 2024. 「고려 후기 염승익의 〈보협인다라니·만다라〉 제작과 주술 치유」 (“Yŏm Sŭngik(廉承益) and Healing through the Conception of the Baoqieyin Dhāra ī-Ma ala Image in the Late Goryeo Dynasty”), 『의사학』 (
Korean journal of medical history ), vol. 33-3, 563-597. 10.13081/kjmh.2024.33.563 39973051 PMC11855048 - 閔賢九. 2025. 「<구미 대둔사 건칠아미타여래좌상> 복장 <보협진언·팔엽삼십칠존만다라>의 제작주체와 조성의도」 (“The Patronage and Intent behind the Production of the ‘Bhautrkā Dhāraṇī Sūtra and Eight-petaled Lotus Maṇḍala of Thirty-seven Deities’ Enshrined in the Dry-Lacquer Seated Amitābha Image of Kumi Taedun-sa”), 『동국사학』 (
Journal of Donguk History ), vol. 84, 57-100. - MIN, Hyon-ku 閔賢九. 1976. 「趙仁規와 그의 家門(上)」 (“Jo In-Kyu (趙仁規) and His Family, vol. 1”), 『震檀學報』 (
Journal of Chindan Studies ), vol. 42, 7-28. - _______. 1977. 「趙仁規와 그의 家門(中)」 (“Jo In-Kyu (趙仁規) and His Family, vol. 2”), 『震檀學報』 (
Journal of Chindan Studies ), vol. 43, 5-32. - NAM, Kwon-heui 남권희. 2007. 「일본 남선사 소장의 고려 초조대장경」 (“A Study on the First Tripitaka Koreana of the Nan-Zen Ji”), 『서지학연구』 (
Journal of Studies in Bibliography ), vol. 36, 81-121. 10.17258/jib.2007..36.81 - PARK, Hye-won 박혜원. 2011. 「고려시대 아미타내영도와 임종의례의 관련성 시론」 (“The Relationship between "Descent of Amitabha" and Deathbed Rituals of the Goryeo Dynasty”), 『미술자료』 (
Journal of Art Materials ), vol, 80, 45-67. - PARK, Young-jin 박용진. 2012. 「고려후기 元版大藏經 印成과 流通」 (“Imprinting and Distribution of Yuan Tripitaka of the Late Goryeo”), 『중앙사론』 (
Journal of Chungang Historical Studies ), vol. 35, 243-277. - _______. 2021. 「고려 후기 『妙法蓮華經三昧懺法』의 간행과 내용 연구」 (“A Study on the Publication and Content of Myobeob-yeonhwagyeongsammaechambeob in the late Goryeo Dynasty”), 『서지학연구』 (
Journal of Studies in Bibliography ), vol. 86, 121-143. - Seinosuke IDE 井手誠之輔. 1995. 「高麗の阿彌陀畫像と普賢行願品」 (“Goryeo Paintings of amitabha and the extraordinary aspiration of the Practice of samantabhadra”), 『美術硏究』 (
Journal of Art Studies ), vol. 362, 1-32. - _______. 2016. 「華嚴と天台の融合-高麗の阿彌陀畫像を手がかりに」 (“The Convergence of Hwaeom and Tiantai: A Study of Goryeo Amitabha Paintings”), 『高麗佛畫-香りたつ裝飾美』 (
The Fragrant Sublime: Koryŏ Buddhist Paintings ), Tokyo: Nezu Museum 根津美術館. - SHU, Jian 舒健. 2020. 「多视角观察: 元朝与高丽宗教交流的新变化」 (“Observation from Multiple Perspectives: New Changes in Religious Exchanges Between the Yuan Dynasty and Koguryo”), 『中国史研究动态』 (
Trends of Recent Researches on the History of China ), vol. 2020-2, 53-58. - SON, Chaehun 손채훈. 2024. 「고려후기 아미타내영도의 연원과 수용 연구」 (“A study on the origin and acceptance painting of descending amitabha buddha in the late Goryeo dynasty”), Master’s thesis, Dong-a University 동아대학교 대학원 석사학위 청구논문.
- The Japanese Government-General of Korea 朝鮮總督府 編. 1918. 『朝鮮古蹟圖譜』 (
Joseongojeokdobo ), vol. 6, Hanseong: The Japanese Government-General of Korea 朝鮮總督府. - YI, Seoung-hui 이승희. 2016. 「고려후기 입상 아미타불도상의 재해석-천태16묘관수행법의 영향을 통해서-」 (“A New Analysis of the Standing Amitaba Images in Late Goryeo Buddhist Paintings: Based on the Influence of the Sixteen Meditations Practice of Tiantai Buddhism”), 『미술사학연구』 (
Korean journal of art history ), vol. 289, 65-91. 10.31065/ahak.289.289.201603.003 - YOSHIDA hiroshi 吉田宏志. 1979. 「至元二十三年銘高麗阿彌陀如來像をめぐつて」 (“regarding the amitabha Buddha of the 23rd year of Zhiyuan”), 『月刊文化財』 (
Monthly Cultural Heritage ), vol. 186, 22-24. - YU, Mari 유마리. 1995. 「1323년 4月作 觀經十六觀變相圖(日本 隣松寺藏)-觀經圖의 연구 Ⅲ」 (“The
Illustrations of the Sixteen Visualizations Dated April 1323 (Held by Rinsho-ji, Japan): A Study ofAmitayurdhyana Sutra Paintings III”), 『문화재』 (Heritage ), vol. 28, 33-56. - ZHANG, Yanmeng 張⾔夢. 1999. 「元代來華⾼麗僧⼈考述」 (“A Study of Goryeo Monks Who Traveled to Yuan China”), 『内蒙古社会科学(汉⽂版)』 (
Inner Mongolia Social Sciences ), vol. 116, 40.
◆ 약호 및 일차 문헌 Abbreviations and Primary Sources
◆ 이차 문헌 Secondary Literature
- Publisher :Korean Association of Buddhist Studies
- Publisher(Ko) :불교학연구회
- Journal Title :Korean Journal of Buddhist Studies
- Journal Title(Ko) :불교학연구
- Volume : 87
- Pages :219∼251
- DOI :https://doi.org/10.21482/jbs.87..202606.219


Korean Journal of Buddhist Studies






